"A or B: My wheel was rusted onto my SUV and I’d been fighting it on the side of the road for over an hour. A mobile mechanic pulled over with a floor jack and a mallet and got it off, and he only took $40 after I pushed it on him three times"
A mechanic stands in front of a vehicle lifted on a jack inside a workshop.
Representative only.
The woman had become stuck on the side of the road, having managed to get the lug nuts off the wheel with the flat tire, however the wheel itself was rusted on.
I was changing a tire on a busy road. The lug nuts came off fine but the wheel wouldn’t budge. It was rusted onto the hub. I’d been at it for over an hour.
Even when a kind stranger stopped to help, the two of them weren't able to get it off.
Another guy stopped and tried too. Nothing.
Story: Educational_Sink8355
A mechanic stands in front of an open hood on a van.
Not actual story subjects.
Luckily, another kind stranger stopped to help. He was a mobile mechanic in his van who happened to be passing by. He managed to get the wheel free with his tools "in minutes"
Then a guy in a work van pulled over. He's a mobile mechanic. He went back to his van, got a heavy floor jack and a mallet, lifted the SUV, and knocked the wheel loose in a few minutes.
But he refused to take payment, only accepting $40 when she continued to insist.
I tried to give him cash. He said, "Nah, you're good." I tried again. Still no. The third time he took $40.
A mechanic wears gloves while focused on the lug nuts of a vehicle's wheel.
Model portrayal.
She felt this wasn't enough to pay him back for his kind deed.
Forty bucks for getting me off the side of that road doesn't feel like enough. His number is on the side of his van.
So, she asked the readers what they would do, giving them the following two options:
A. Venmo him more on top of the $40.
B. Book him for my next repair and leave him a review that tells the whole story.
What would you do?
So what do you think? What should she do to repay him?
A car tire rests beside a concrete curb littered with dry, fallen autumn leaves.
Scene shown is a visual representation.
If you've ever had to change a wheel on your car at the side of the road, you know it's a pretty stressful situation. And when it's on the side of a busy road, it's quite literally dangerous too. The last place you want to be is outside of your vehicle with all the others rushing past, with your presence also becoming a distraction and point of fixation for the other drivers.
Even if you're pretty comfortable doing your own vehicle maintenance, fiddling around with the little jack and whatever tire iron you have in the back of the car isn't the same as doing it on your flat driveway with your socket set and garage jack.
If you do happen to get a flat tire, though, sound advice I have found and used myself is to:
1. Carefully slow down; don't jam on the brakes.
2. Get to a safe spot, pull off the road as far as you safely can.
3. Keep kids and passengers in the car, and anyone else who doesn't need to be out of the vehicle.
4. Make sure your hazard lights are on
5. Change the wheel to the spare or repair the tire yourself. (Or call roadside assistance.)
If the wheel is stuck, you might want to call roadside assistance, but there are some great YouTube videos on how to do this. (Although maybe sitting on the side of a busy road watching YouTube on your phone isn't the best idea.)
But, as this article advises, if you have a rust penetrant on hand, or there is a block of wood handy nearby, you can use the added force to help knock it free.
But if you don't know what you're doing, defer to the experts and get help as soon as you can.
Removing a rusted-on vehicle part is pretty tricky. I had a wheel that was rusted on when I was trying to work on my vehicle and had to remove the wheel to work on the clutch.
In the end, I couldn't get it off; I had to give up. I had to take it to my mechanic and get him to do it, and he wasn't super stoked about it either. It sounded like he had one heck of a time getting it off.
So, without a doubt, this mobile mechanic did a kind service. But how should he be repaid?
Let's see how readers of the original thread voted…
Of 63 responses that I was reasonably able to check and discern, this was the split:
A: Venmo him more on top of the $40. - 0 votes - 0.0%
B: Book him for a repair and leave him a review that tells the whole story. - 44 votes - 69.8%
Both A and B: Send more money and support his business - 4 votes - 6.3%
C: Explicit C vote, other advice, or conditional answer - 8 votes - 12.7%
Off topic: Side conversations about other roadside stories or videos - 4 votes - 6.3%
Unclear: No recommendation 3 votes - 4.8%
Going off pure numbers alone, it would appear that B was the clear favorite and this is sound advice. He clearly wasn't after an extra buck, so bombarding him with more money that he had already rejected isn't the answer.
In my opinion, the top-voted comment got it right this time around. They suggested that she write him a 5-star review but not include the part where he refused to accept payment.
This is great advice, because as soon as people saw in the reviews that they might get something for free from him, he would be swarmed by choosing beggars demanding all kinds of services for free.
The original poster, Educational_Sink8355, replied several times in this thread, suggesting that this would be the course of action she would take.
What do you think? What should she have done?
Read the key responses below and then share your thoughts with me.
The Responses
Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.